BOSTON (OSV News) — The Boston Archdiocese has told a Catholic church in suburban Dedham to remove a “politically divisive” sign about U.S. Customs and Immigration Enforcement (ICE) from its Nativity scene outside the church.
But Father Steve Josoma, St. Susanna’s pastor, refused to do so and said he wants to discuss it with Boston Archbishop Richard G. Henning.
In a Dec. 6 statement, the archdiocese said, “The people of God have the right to expect that, when they come to church, they will encounter genuine opportunities for prayer and Catholic worship — not divisive political messaging.”
“The Church’s norms prohibit the use of sacred objects for any purpose other than the devotion of God’s people. This includes images of the Christ Child in the manger, which are to be used solely to foster faith and devotion,” it said.
“St. Susanna Parish neither requested nor received permission from the Archdiocese to depart from this canonical norm or to place a politically divisive display outside the church. The display should be removed, and the manger restored to its proper sacred purpose,” the statement concluded.
Father Josoma said during a press conference late Dec. 8 he won’t remove it until he can speak to Archbishop Henning.
‘ICE’ sign sparks debate
The archdiocesan statement came in response to St. Susanna’s decision to replace the scene’s Jesus, Joseph and Mary figurines with a sign that reads: “ICE was here.” Below that sits a smaller one that reads “The Holy Family is safe in our Church … If you see ICE please call LUCE at 617-370-5023.” LUCE is the Immigrant Justice Network of Massachusetts.
The ICE sign is an apparent reference to recent ICE operations underway in Massachusetts to apprehend unauthorized migrants in the country, and implies ICE came looking for the Holy Family to take them into custody.
A recent ICE news release said the agency “and federal law enforcement partners apprehended more than 1,400 illegal aliens during a weeks-long immigration enforcement operation focusing on transnational organized crime, gangs and egregious illegal alien offenders throughout the Commonwealth of Massachusetts.”
According to a CBS News report, the Nativity scene containing the sign at St. Susanna Nativity was put up Nov. 29, the Saturday after Thanksgiving, “and within hours it had sparked debate online.”
OSV News did not receive a response to its query emailed to the archdiocesan communications office asking if the pastor has asked for a meeting with the archbishop.
Dialogue or exploitation?
“The Vatican itself displays different themed Nativities each year highlighting social issues to contemporary life,” Father Josoma said during the press conference outside the church. “Our hope was to similarly evoke dialogue around an issue that is at the heart of contemporary life.”
He may have been referring to the Vatican Nativity scene in 2024, designed as “a message of humility and communion,” according to Vatican News. The scene was “modeled after a traditional ‘casone’ from the Grado Lagoon (with) humble fisherman’s huts, built with simple materials like mud and reeds.”
The Vatican’s Nativity scene for this year comes from the province of Salerno, in Campania, from the Diocese of Nocera Inferiore-Sarno. “It incorporates typical elements of the Nocera area,” the Vatican said, including an early Christian baptistery of the town of Nocera Superiore, a typical courtyard house from the Agro Nocerino area, elements of the territory and “figures exemplary of local spirituality,” such as St. Alfonsus Liguori.
C.J. Doyle, executive director of the Catholic Action League of Massachusetts, told Boston 25 News TV station Father Jasoma is “politicizing Christmas. He’s exploiting the Holy Family. He’s using his position as the pastor of a Catholic parish to promote his left-wing political ideology.”
